StratumSkin science, cited
Ingredient Index

Keloid & scar-prone skin

Silicone gel sheets

Scar treatment, worn as sheets or applied as gel

Overall grade CTypical strength Worn 12–24 hours/day over a scar for 2–3 months2 sources

The most-studied topical scar treatment on the market, and often described as first-line. But the Cochrane reviews behind that reputation are more hedged than the reputation suggests. Real trials exist, more of them than for anything else we found for scarring, and Cochrane's own language is 'weak evidence' and 'poor quality,' not a ringing endorsement. It is, in other words, the most rigorously studied shrug in dermatology. Worth trying, priced and framed as a reasonable first step rather than a proven fix.

Claim by claim

CPreventing abnormal scarring in high-risk woundsCochrane's own summary: 'weak evidence of a benefit... but the poor quality of research means a great deal of uncertainty prevails.'
CTreating existing hypertrophic scarsA narrower, more recent Cochrane review (13 trials, 468 participants) rated nearly all outcomes 'low or very low' certainty evidence.
CVs. onion extract gel specificallyThe same review found silicone sheeting may modestly beat onion extract gel on appearance. It's a low-certainty comparison, but the clearer of the two products' evidence.

References

  1. O'Brien L, Jones DJ. Silicone gel sheeting for preventing and treating hypertrophic and keloid scars. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2013.CCochrane systematic review, 20 trials, 873 participants·Direct quote: 'Most of the studies identified were of poor quality.' A real, if uncertain, benefit, not the settled first-line evidence its reputation suggests.DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD003826.pub3
  2. Jiang Q, Chen J, Tian F, Liu Z. Silicone gel sheeting for treating hypertrophic scars. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2021.CCochrane systematic review, 13 trials, 468 participants·Narrower review focused on treating (not preventing) existing hypertrophic scars. Nearly every outcome was rated low or very low certainty, and it 'may slightly improve appearance' compared with onion extract specifically.PubMed 34564840DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD013357.pub2

Related condition hub

Keloid & scar-prone skin

Your turn

Did this hold up? Tell us honestly — especially if it didn’t.

Anonymous. Stored in your browser.

The Sunday study

One paper a week, explained properly

We pick a single new study, tell you what it measured, how many people it measured it in, and whether it should change anything you're doing — plus the two articles we published that week. No panic, and no hype.

We don't recommend products yet. When we do, they'll be things you can actually buy in India, any affiliate link will be labelled as one, and a commission will never buy a recommendation.

One email each Sunday. Unsubscribe in one click.