Niacinamide rebuilds your barrier1, fades dark spots slowly2, and does almost nothing for wrinkles3.
Three claims about one ingredient, each resting on a different quality of evidence. Most skincare writing blurs that together. We keep it visible.
Sources for this statement
3 studies
Flip the switch. Each numbered claim in the headline will show the study behind it — what kind of study, how many people, which journal, and how much weight it can carry.
1
Barrier: it helps skin rebuild the fatty mortar that holds it together.
BControlled human application·n=~30·Br J Dermatol·2000
2
Pigment: dark spots do fade, over roughly eight weeks, modestly.
Wrinkles: machines can measure a change. Your mirror probably can't.
CRCT, manufacturer-funded·n=50·Dermatol Surg·2005
What the Stratum Grade means
Every claim and every ingredient on this site carries one of four grades. Here is exactly what each one is telling you — and a longer explainer on how we get there.
A
Well established
Backed by systematic reviews or several separate randomised controlled trials that point the same way. Different research groups, different patients, same result. This is as certain as skincare gets.
B
Good evidence
At least one properly run human trial with a control group, but it hasn't been widely repeated yet. Probably true. Worth acting on. Not yet carved in stone.
C
Suggestive
Small studies, no control group, or research paid for by whoever sells the ingredient. None of that makes it wrong. It does mean the result could shrink or vanish when someone independent checks.
D
Lab only
Tested on cells in a dish or on animals, never on actual people using it on actual skin. Plenty of ingredients look brilliant in a petri dish and do nothing on a face.
Latest articles
Long reads on ingredients, treatments and the studies behind them, written to be understood without a biology degree. Two new pieces go up each week.
The rest of the publication — condition guides, the myths we've put on trial, everywhere we've been wrong and fixed it, and how to send us your own question.
Three short pieces go up on the site each week. On Sunday we take a single study — usually a new one, occasionally an old one everybody has been misquoting — and give it the long treatment. That piece is the newsletter. It lands in your inbox and lives here afterwards. Every piece here is already graded on its own card below, so a second board just repeating those same grades back as a chart didn't earn its place on this page.
The first Sunday Study is being written. Sign up below and it will reach you before it reaches this page.
No article in this topic carries that grade yet. Try widening the dropdown.
BTreatments·9 min·3 sources
Microneedling for acne scars: depth is the whole conversation
The trials that show real improvement used depths and session counts that home rollers cannot reach. That's not a detail: it's the mechanism.
The Stratum Editorsnot clinicians·Not yet reviewed by a clinicianUpdated 15 August 2026
Disclosure
Nothing here is sponsored and we earn nothing from anything mentioned. If that ever changes, this box will say so before you read a word of the article.
Evidence at a glance
Rolling scars
B Clear improvement in controlled trials. Not erasure.
Ice-pick scars
C Responds poorly. Needs different treatment.
Depth that works
C Deep enough to reach the dermis. The threshold is convention, not a tested number.
Home rollers
D Usually 0.25–0.5 mm. Below the depth that was studied.
Sessions needed
B Typically three to six, a month apart.
Microneedling is one of the few in-clinic treatments where the evidence is decent, the mechanism makes sense, and the home version has almost nothing to do with the thing that was tested.
Why controlled injury helps
An atrophic acne scar is a small dent: a patch where the skin healed with less collagen than it started with. You cannot fill a dent by moisturising it.
Microneedling makes hundreds of tiny, controlled punctures that trigger a wound-healing response. Your body lays down new collagen while repairing them, and over several rounds the floor of the scar rises. It's a slow rebuild, not a resurfacing.
Randomised trials in atrophic acne scarring consistently show meaningful improvement in scar severity scores after a course of treatment. Not perfect skin. Meaningful improvement, which for deep scarring is a substantial result.
The number that decides everything
The trials showing benefit use depths that reach the dermis, generally described as 1.5 mm and above, delivered over multiple sessions spaced two to four weeks apart. The meta-analysis we cite pools treatment effects rather than settling the depth question, so treat that number as working consensus rather than a tested threshold. That is where collagen gets made.
What the exact optimum is remains unsettled. One split-face study treated both sides of 14 faces, at 2.5 mm on one side and 1.5 mm on the other, and found the deeper setting worked better. Fourteen people is a very small study, so read that as a hint rather than a protocol.
Home rollers sold for skincare are typically 0.25 to 0.5 mm. That depth doesn't reliably reach the layer that responds. It's not a weaker version of the studied treatment. It's a different thing that shares a name.
There's a second problem. Rollers drag the needles through skin at an angle rather than entering straight down, and home devices are notoriously difficult to sterilise properly between uses.
If a home device could reach the depth used in the trials, it would need the aftercare, the anaesthetic and the infection control that go with it. The reason it's safe to sell you is the same reason it doesn't work.
Which scars respond, and which don't
Rolling scars: broad, shallow, wavy. The best responders.
Boxcar scars: sharp-edged, shallow to medium. Reasonable response.
Ice-pick scars: narrow and deep. Poor response. These usually need a technique that treats each scar individually.
Most people have a mixture, which is why a good clinician will often combine approaches rather than sell you a single course of anything.
Before you book
Treat the acne first. Needling actively inflamed skin can spread bacteria and cause more scarring than it repairs. If you still get regular breakouts, that's the problem to solve first, and it's the cheaper one.
If you have darker skin, ask specifically about the operator's experience with your skin tone. Any controlled injury carries a risk of post-inflammatory pigmentation, and technique matters enormously here.
Realistic expectations
Published trials report substantial falls in scar severity scores over a full course. We have not pinned a specific percentage range to a source we have read in full, so we are not going to quote you one. That's a genuinely good outcome and it is not the same as clear skin. Anyone promising erasure is either selling something or hasn't read the studies.
Results also keep developing for months after the final session, because collagen remodelling is slow. Judging the outcome at six weeks is judging it too early.
The short version
Worth doing, in a clinic, for rolling and boxcar scars, after your acne is under control, over three to six sessions, with realistic expectations. The roller in your bathroom drawer is doing something closer to nothing.
This is general education, not medical advice. Nothing here accounts for your history, your medication or your skin, and none of it replaces assessment by a qualified clinician. Where we describe what research found, that is a description of a study — not a promise about you.
References
Sitohang IBS, Sirait SAP, Suryanegara J. Microneedling in the treatment of atrophic scars: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials. International Wound Journal, 2021.BSystematic review of RCTs·Authors declared no conflict of interestPubMed 33538106DOI 10.1111/iwj.13559
Chen SX, Cheng J, Watchmaker J, et al. Microneedling monotherapy for acne scar: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2022.BMeta-analysis of 12 RCTs, n=414·Pools treatment effect across 12 RCTs. Does not itself establish an optimal needle depth.PubMed 35426044DOI 10.1007/s00266-022-02845-3
El-Domyati M, Moftah NH, Ahmed AM, Ibrahim MR. Evaluation of microneedling depth of penetration in management of atrophic acne scars: a split-face comparative study. International Journal of Dermatology, 2024.CSplit-face comparison, n=14, six sessions·Very small, but no declared funding or conflict. Found 2.5 mm outperformed 1.5 mm, but that's preliminary, not settledPubMed 38159109DOI 10.1111/ijd.17006
Did this hold up? Tell us honestly — especially if it didn’t.
Anonymous. Stored in your browser.
Ingredient Index
Every ingredient, graded on what the trials show
Sorted by evidence, not by popularity. Where a claim rests on one small study, we say so.
Where the evidence sits
60 ingredients
There are far fewer Grade A entries than Grade C. That gap is the point of the index.
Reading the grades
The letter next to each ingredient tells you how confident anyone can reasonably be — not how well it works, but how well we know it works. A Grade C ingredient isn’t bad. It’s unproven.
A
Well established
Backed by systematic reviews or several separate randomised controlled trials that point the same way. Different research groups, different patients, same result. This is as certain as skincare gets.
B
Good evidence
At least one properly run human trial with a control group, but it hasn't been widely repeated yet. Probably true. Worth acting on. Not yet carved in stone.
C
Suggestive
Small studies, no control group, or research paid for by whoever sells the ingredient. None of that makes it wrong. It does mean the result could shrink or vanish when someone independent checks.
D
Lab only
Tested on cells in a dish or on animals, never on actual people using it on actual skin. Plenty of ingredients look brilliant in a petri dish and do nothing on a face.
Nothing matches that combination. Try widening one of the dropdowns — there simply aren't many Grade A ingredients, which is rather the point.
Conditions
Start from what's actually bothering you
The Ingredient Index and Articles are organised by molecule and by topic. These pages are organised by the question you actually arrived with — pulling together everything graded so far, in one place, ranked by how good the evidence is rather than how the page is titled.
Where the hub evidence sits
52 ingredients cited
Every ingredient referenced from a condition hub, by grade — pulled straight from the Ingredient Index, not graded separately for appearing here.
Every grade on this site is a judgment call, made using the same handful of questions each time. This page is those questions, written out, so you can apply them yourself the next time a bottle promises something a study never quite said.
Start with who ran it, and who paid for it
The single fastest useful question. A study funded by a company that sells the ingredient it's testing isn't automatically wrong. Several of our entries rest on exactly that kind of study, graded accordingly. But it tells you how much independent scrutiny the result has actually had, and how surprised to be if an unfunded lab finds something smaller later. We name the funder in every reference we publish, for that reason.
Ask what was actually measured
‘Improved skin texture’ can mean a dermatologist's visual scale, a machine reading of elasticity, or two researchers agreeing a photograph looked better. None of those is fake, but they're not the same claim, and only one is close to what you'd notice in a mirror. The word ‘endpoint’ or ‘outcome measure’ in a study tells you what was actually tracked, as against what a press release implies was tracked.
Check who was in it, and whether there was a control group
A trial of 14 people is a hint, not a verdict. Several of our Grade C entries rest on studies exactly that size. A trial with no control group can't separate the treatment's effect from time passing, a change in weather, or the placebo effect, all of which move skin measurements on their own. ‘Randomised’ and ‘controlled’ in a study's description are doing real work, and their absence is worth noticing.
Significant is a statistics word, not a mirror word
When a paper calls a result ‘statistically significant’, it means the result was unlikely to be chance. It doesn't mean it's large, and it doesn't mean you'd see it. Our own niacinamide piece cites a wrinkle study that was significant on measuring instruments and never asked whether anyone could see the difference. Both facts can be true of the same study: the effect is real, and may be too small to matter to you.
One study is a data point, not a verdict
Individual trials go wrong for ordinary reasons: a small sample, an unusual population, plain bad luck. That's what systematic reviews and meta-analyses are for: pooling several trials to see whether an effect holds up across them. We grade a claim higher when independent studies agree, and say so plainly when a grade rests on one trial that hasn't yet been repeated.
Watch for the sorting trick
Our collagen peptides correction is the clearest example on this site. Pooled together, the trials showed a benefit. Split by who funded them, the benefit lived almost entirely in the industry-funded studies. The pooled number wasn't fabricated. It was real, and it was also hiding something a funding breakdown revealed immediately. Whenever a pooled result surprises you, it's worth asking whether it survives being split by quality or funding.
How that becomes a Stratum Grade
The four grades below are the same ones attached to every ingredient, claim and article on this site. They describe how well something is known, never how well it works.
A
Well established
Backed by systematic reviews or several separate randomised controlled trials that point the same way. Different research groups, different patients, same result. This is as certain as skincare gets.
B
Good evidence
At least one properly run human trial with a control group, but it hasn't been widely repeated yet. Probably true. Worth acting on. Not yet carved in stone.
C
Suggestive
Small studies, no control group, or research paid for by whoever sells the ingredient. None of that makes it wrong. It does mean the result could shrink or vanish when someone independent checks.
D
Lab only
Tested on cells in a dish or on animals, never on actual people using it on actual skin. Plenty of ingredients look brilliant in a petri dish and do nothing on a face.
Claims on trial
The internet's favourite claims, graded fast
Whatever's trending on skincare Instagram or YouTube this month, in three or four paragraphs rather than a full article — one claim, one verdict, one grade. Have one for us to look at? Send it in.
Verdicts so far
17 claims
Grade describes how solid the verdict itself is — not how popular or plausible the original claim sounds.
D“Rubbing an ice cube on your face shrinks your pores.”
Verdict: False. Pores have no muscle around them, so nothing about them can physically shrink or tighten in response to temperature. What ice does is cause brief vasoconstriction in the small vessels near the surface, which can calm visible redness and make pores look marginally less obvious for a few minutes. It's a lighting effect, not a structural change, and it reverses as your skin warms back up. We aren't aware of a trial testing this specific claim, so read the grade as our reasoned view of established physiology rather than a sourced verdict.
2 September 2026
D“Steam or heat 'opens' your pores so cleanser and extractions work better, and cold water 'closes' them afterward.”
Verdict: False. Pores don't have a hinge that opens and shuts them. Heat can soften the sebum plugging a pore, which genuinely helps during an extraction, but that's softening a blockage, not opening a structure. Cold water afterward causes the same brief vasoconstriction as the ice-cube claim above, and it doesn't seal anything. This is our reasoned view of the underlying anatomy, not a claim resting on a specific cited trial.
2 September 2026
A“SPF 100 sunscreen gives you roughly twice the protection of SPF 50.”
Verdict: False, the maths doesn't work that way. SPF describes what fraction of UVB gets filtered out, and that scale isn't linear. SPF 30 filters about 96.7% of UVB, SPF 50 about 98%, SPF 100 about 99%. Each step up buys a shrinking sliver of extra filtration, not a doubling. The gap that actually matters, with randomised trial evidence behind it, is between applying enough sunscreen and applying too little: real-world application runs well under half of what's used to earn the number on the bottle in the first place.
D“'Natural' or 'organic' ingredients are inherently gentler and safer on skin than synthetic ones.”
Verdict: Not supported. Where a molecule comes from tells you nothing on its own about how it behaves on skin. Essential oils, entirely natural, are among the best-documented causes of cosmetic contact allergy on our own Ingredient Index. Dimethicone, entirely synthetic, is one of the better-tolerated ingredients we've graded. 'Natural' is a marketing category, not a safety one.
D“Drinking more water noticeably hydrates or 'plumps' your skin.”
Verdict: Overstated. Once you're adequately hydrated, drinking extra water on top of that has not been shown to meaningfully change skin hydration or appearance. Your kidneys regulate where that water goes, not your face. A humectant applied directly to skin acts on it far more directly and has actual controlled evidence behind it. Staying hydrated is good for you for reasons that have nothing to do with your skin.
2 September 2026
C“You should chemically exfoliate with an acid every single day for the best results.”
Verdict: Overstated, and often counterproductive. The acids on our Ingredient Index have real evidence behind them, and nearly all of it comes from studies using them a few times a week, not daily. Daily use pushes many people past what their barrier can keep up with, showing up as the stinging, redness and tightness our barrier-repair piece describes as damage rather than progress. More often stops being more effective well before 'every day'.
C“A turmeric (haldi) paste applied to the face clears acne and brightens skin.”
Verdict: Unproven for acne, unsupported for brightening. The one trial usually cited for this is a real randomised, placebo-controlled study of an Ayurvedic acne formulation. But turmeric was one of several herbal ingredients in it, so the trial cannot tell you what turmeric alone did. A newer study testing curcumin for acne used an oral capsule, not a paste, and wasn't randomised or blinded. For skin brightening specifically, a 2023 review of topical curcumin research found no controlled human studies at all. What is well documented, across multiple independent case reports going back to the 1980s, is that turmeric and curcumin can cause allergic contact dermatitis and, less commonly, contact urticaria (hives where it touched the skin). Worth knowing before you leave a paste on your face for an hour because a video told you to.
2 September 2026
D“A besan (gram flour) face mask exfoliates and brightens skin.”
Verdict: No controlled evidence found. We looked for any randomised or controlled human trial of besan applied to skin and found none. What exists is a review of centuries-old Persian traditional medicine texts describing chickpea's traditional uses, plus generic phytochemistry. That's theoretical rationale, not a tested result. It doesn't mean it does nothing or that it's unsafe as a mild, low-cost scrub. It means the brightening and exfoliating claims are traditional use dressed up as a skincare result, not something a trial has actually checked.
2 September 2026
D“Multani mitti (Fuller's earth) face masks control oil and brighten skin.”
Verdict: No controlled evidence found. We could not find a single controlled human trial of Fuller's earth on skin, for oil control, brightening, or anything else. A 2025 trial did find a clay-based mask reduced acne severity, but that trial used bentonite, a chemically different clay, combined with an added herbal extract, so it can't be used to support Multani mitti specifically even if the two get marketed as interchangeable. As a mechanical oil-absorbing mask it's plausible and almost certainly low-risk for most people. As a tested skincare treatment, there's nothing behind it yet.
2 September 2026
B“Coconut oil is a good moisturiser, and also has anti-ageing benefits.”
Verdict: Half right. The moisturising half holds up: two separate randomised trials (one comparing it directly to mineral oil in adults with dry skin, one in children with atopic dermatitis) found it performed comparably to standard moisturisers on objective hydration and barrier measures. The anti-ageing half doesn't: a 2025 systematic review of randomised trials on plant-based anti-ageing topicals didn't include a single coconut oil study, and the only 'anti-ageing' coconut oil research we could find was a mouse study of a combination product, not human evidence of any kind. Use it as a moisturiser with a genuinely reasonable evidence base behind that specific claim, and treat the wrinkle-fighting reputation as marketing, not data.
2 September 2026
D“Rice water toner brightens skin, shrinks pores, and gives you glass skin.”
Verdict: No controlled evidence found. Rice water is starch-heavy runoff from washed or fermented rice, and it does contain some real antioxidants, ferulic acid and small amounts of B vitamins and amino acids among them. What it doesn't have behind it is a single controlled trial testing 'rice water toner' on human skin for brightening, pore size, or the 'glass skin' look, despite how widely it circulates on Korean and Indian beauty content. Pores also have no muscle to contract, so nothing topical, this included, physically shrinks them; a diluted starch rinse can leave a slightly smoother, more light-reflective surface for a few hours, which is likely what 'glass skin' photos are actually capturing. Fermented rice water adds an extra risk: home fermentation is uncontrolled, and applying an unregulated, unpreserved liquid to your face for days risks bacterial contamination more than any skincare benefit. Treat this as an unstudied home remedy, not a proven active.
14 September 2026
A“You don't need sunscreen indoors or on a cloudy, overcast day.”
Verdict: False. This one is settled photobiology. Window glass blocks almost all UVB, which is why you don't sunburn through a car window, but UVA passes through glass largely unfiltered, and UVA is the wavelength most responsible for photoaging, pigmentation, and a real share of skin cancer risk. Hours spent near a bright window or driving add up to meaningful cumulative UVA exposure over months and years. Clouds don't solve this either: cloud cover typically blocks somewhere around a fifth to two-fifths of UV, not all of it, which is exactly why sunburn on an overcast day is a common, well-documented experience rather than a myth. Indoor artificial lighting contributes negligible UV next to daylight through glass. None of this rests on a bespoke trial; it follows directly from decades of established physics on how UVA and UVB behave. Sitting near a window for long stretches, or under an overcast sky, still calls for sunscreen.
14 September 2026
D“Dabbing toothpaste on a pimple overnight dries it out and clears it fast.”
Verdict: Backfires more than it helps. Older toothpaste formulas containing triclosan and strong menthol did have some antibacterial and drying action, which is the entire basis for this trick, but that's incidental to ingredients meant for teeth, not a designed acne treatment, and dermatologists have warned against it for years. Toothpaste is formulated to sit briefly in a rinsed mouth, not overnight on skin: sodium lauryl sulfate, baking soda, hydrogen peroxide, and menthol or eucalyptol oils are common irritants at skin-contact strength, and can cause redness, burning, peeling, or even chemical burns on already-inflamed acne. On darker skin tones, that irritation frequently heals into post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation that lasts far longer than the pimple would have. We could not find a controlled trial testing toothpaste against acne; what exists instead is a steady record of case reports and dermatologist warnings about the damage it causes. Any 'drying' effect is closer to a mild chemical burn than a treatment.
14 September 2026
C“Face yoga and facial exercises reduce wrinkles and lift sagging skin.”
Verdict: Thin but real evidence. This is one of the rare face-shaping claims with an actual study behind it. Northwestern University researchers had women in their 40s to 60s follow a 20-week program of specific facial exercises, then had dermatologists blindly estimate participants' ages from before-and-after photos, published in JAMA Dermatology in 2018. Estimated age dropped by roughly three years on average, and cheek fullness scored better too. That's a genuine, published finding, but the fine print matters: there was no control group, so there's no way to separate the exercises from researchers photographing people more carefully at the end, or from unrelated changes over five months. Twenty-seven women enrolled and only sixteen completed the full program, a small, self-selected group. It's the best evidence that exists in either direction on this claim and is worth taking seriously, but it remains one small, uncontrolled pilot study, not a repeated or controlled result.
14 September 2026
D“A home dermaroller (0.5mm or longer) is just as effective as professional microneedling in a clinic.”
Verdict: False, and riskier than advertised. These are different procedures sharing a name. Clinical microneedling for acne scarring, the version with actual randomised trial support, typically works at 1.5-2.5mm needle depth, under sterile conditions, often after numbing, because that depth is what triggers a real wound-healing collagen response. Home dermarollers are capped around 0.3-0.5mm by design, shallow enough to limit serious injury from unsupervised use, but also too shallow to reproduce that clinical effect; at best they may modestly aid product penetration. Rolling deeper than that at home, sometimes marketed as more 'effective', is where this turns genuinely risky: without medical training, single-use sterile needles and a controlled setting, deeper home use has been linked in published case reports to facial infection, allergic granulomas (particularly when active serums are rolled in), and scarring — the opposite of the goal. We found no trial directly comparing home rollers against clinic microneedling head to head, and the depth gap alone explains why they shouldn't be assumed equivalent.
C“Pure aloe vera gel is one of the best things you can use for acne-prone skin.”
Verdict: Overstated. Aloe vera has some real trial support, just not as a stand-alone acne treatment. A randomised, double-blind trial published in the Journal of Dermatological Treatment found aloe vera gel added on top of tretinoin cream outperformed tretinoin plus a placebo gel for mild-to-moderate acne. A more recent randomised trial testing aloe vera gel combined with propolis as an add-on to benzoyl peroxide also reported better improvement in acne severity than benzoyl peroxide alone. In both cases, aloe was riding alongside an actual proven acne active, not replacing one. Used alone, its soothing gel can genuinely calm redness and irritation, which matters on skin already being treated, but we found no trial where aloe by itself outperformed or matched a real acne treatment. 'One of the best things for acne-prone skin' oversells a supporting-cast ingredient into a lead role the data hasn't given it.
D“Cold showers or cold water tighten your skin and shrink your pores.”
Verdict: False. Same physiology as rubbing an ice cube on your face, just with a shower instead. Pores have no muscle fibres around them, so they can't physically dilate or contract in response to water temperature, and skin firmness comes from collagen and elastin structure in the dermis, which a cold rinse doesn't touch. What cold water does cause is brief vasoconstriction: the small vessels near the surface narrow, which can slightly reduce visible redness and puffiness and make skin feel firmer for a few minutes as it cools. That's a temperature effect on blood flow, not a structural change to pore size or elasticity, and it reverses once skin returns to normal temperature. We aren't aware of any trial testing cold showers against pore size or skin tightness specifically, so this grade reflects our reading of basic skin physiology rather than a study we're citing.
14 September 2026
Skin of colour
Where melanin-rich skin needs more than a footnote
Most dermatology trials, textbook photos and marketing claims default to lighter skin. That shows up in real ways for skin of colour — Black, South Asian, East Asian, Hispanic and Middle Eastern skin among others: conditions that look and present differently, a much higher post-inflammatory pigmentation and keloid risk, treatments that need retuning rather than just reusing, and whole topics (razor bumps, traction alopecia) that barely exist in mainstream skincare content at all. This page pulls together everything on the site that speaks to that directly, still graded on the same A–D scale as everywhere else — nothing here is graded more generously for appearing on this page.
Most dermatology trials and textbook photos default to lighter skin
Fitzpatrick I–III skin is overrepresented in both the clinical trials behind most ingredient grades and the reference photos clinicians train on. That doesn't make the underlying findings wrong, but it does mean some conditions look different than the reference picture, present later, or get treated with an ingredient tested mainly on skin unlike the reader's. Where we know a study specifically included darker skin, the reference note says so.
Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation is often the bigger complaint than what caused it
Acne, eczema and psoriasis all can leave marks that outlast the original flare by months, and in medium-to-deep skin tones that mark is often what actually brings someone to a dermatologist or this site. It tilts good treatment choice toward options less likely to irritate in the first place, since irritation itself can trigger more of it.
Melasma and post-inflammatory marks respond to visible light on top of UV, and a plain SPF number says nothing about that. An independent trial found iron-oxide-tinted sunscreen measurably boosted hydroquinone's own treatment effect; a separate, industry-funded trial found less relapse afterward with the same kind of sunscreen versus a clear or white one at the same SPF.
Keloid risk is one of dermatology's best-documented skin-of-colour differences
The gap in keloid incidence by skin tone is large and consistently replicated, which makes it worth mentioning to a dermatologist before an elective piercing, tattoo or procedure if you or a close relative scars this way — a five-minute conversation ahead of time beats months of treating a keloid afterward.
Pseudofolliculitis barbae is overwhelmingly a problem of tightly curled hair curling back into the skin after a close shave, which makes it far more common in Black men than the generic shaving-tips content most razor marketing is written for ever accounts for. The definitive fixes (growing out, laser, a guarded trimmer) are more effective than almost anything applied on top of the bumps themselves.
A widely repeated hair-loss cause turned out to be only part of the story
Central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia was blamed on relaxers and tight hairstyles for years. A 2019 genetics study found an identifiable gene variant in about a quarter of patients tested, including some who never used those practices, which complicates the tidy single-cause version still repeated across a lot of hair-care content — without genetics alone explaining most cases either.
From the Products section — formulas that contain at least one ingredient listed above, checked the same way as every other product here: formula against claim, not the other way round.
Most dermatology trials are run in temperate climates on Fitzpatrick I–III skin — the paler end of the six-type scale dermatologists use to classify how skin responds to sun, with VI the darkest. That doesn't make the findings wrong, but it does mean some of them need a footnote before they apply here. This is that footnote, collected in one place.
Daily sunscreen is the highest-leverage step available, and the most skipped
Most of India sits at latitudes with strong, fairly consistent UV exposure through the year. There's no real off-season the way there is in the temperate climates most sunscreen trials come from. That makes the case for daily, all-year application stronger here than the studies alone convey, even though the studies themselves were mostly run elsewhere.
A lot of the pigmentation evidence wasn't tested on skin like yours
Trials on hydroquinone, tranexamic acid and several other depigmenting agents were often run on lighter Fitzpatrick skin types than are common across India. Where we could find a study that specifically included Fitzpatrick IV–VI skin (azelaic acid's darker-skin trials, for instance) we say so in the reference notes. Where we couldn't, treat the grade as a description of the general evidence, not a guarantee it transfers directly.
Humidity plus air conditioning is a harder environment on your barrier than most advice assumes
Skincare advice written for steadier, drier climates tends to underestimate how much moving between humid outdoor air and dry, air-conditioned indoor air in the same day stresses a skin barrier. If barrier advice elsewhere on this site isn't working as fast as described, this swing is a plausible reason, and it's worth simplifying your routine further than a temperate-climate guide would suggest.
India's 2026 advertising rules are part of why we disclose the way we do
ASCI's guidelines for influencer and affiliate marketing in India set specific requirements for how a paid or affiliate relationship must be disclosed: prominently, in plain language, before the reader reaches the product. We have no affiliate relationships or sponsorships to disclose yet, but the format we'll use once we do (a disclosure banner at the top of the article, not a line buried in the footer) is built around those rules rather than the lighter norms common elsewhere.
A drug's international name and its Indian brand name are often different
Several ingredients we've graded are sold under brand names in India that don't obviously match the generic name used in the trial we're citing. Where that's likely to cause confusion we're working through it condition by condition. Until then, checking the actual INCI ingredient list on a product against the Ingredient Index is more reliable than matching brand names.
Fungal acne gets misdiagnosed here more than the evidence would suggest it should
The heat and humidity that make Malassezia folliculitis common in India also mean it spends a long time being treated as ordinary acne, with benzoyl peroxide and retinoids that don't touch a yeast overgrowth and can even make it itchier. If chest and back bumps haven't budged after a proper course of acne treatment, this is worth ruling out before trying something stronger.
PCOS is common here and its skin symptoms are routinely treated in isolation
PCOS is thought to affect a large share of Indian women of reproductive age, and jawline acne or new hair growth is often the first sign. It gets treated for months as a skincare problem before anyone checks for the hormonal condition underneath it. A dermatologist can treat the skin, but only a broader workup catches PCOS itself.
Keloid risk runs higher in darker skin tones, which describes a lot of India
Routine procedures elsewhere treated as low-risk (ear piercing, a vaccination, a minor cut) carry a meaningfully higher chance of raised, spreading scarring here than the skin-tone assumptions baked into a lot of imported skincare advice account for. Worth mentioning to a dermatologist before an elective piercing or procedure if you or a close relative scars this way.
Traditional home remedies deserve the same scrutiny as any serum
Turmeric, besan and Multani mitti show up in skincare routines across India long before any of them show up in a dermatologist's office, and that history doesn't automatically make them tested. We've started grading the most common ones on the Claims on Trial page the same way we grade a serum: plainly, and without assuming tradition and evidence are the same thing.
Everywhere we've been wrong, and what we did about it
We would rather be publicly wrong once than quietly wrong forever. Every time new evidence moves a grade, or we catch something we got wrong the first time, it's logged here with the date and what changed — nothing gets quietly edited out.
Added a breastfeeding-specific section on benzoyl peroxide. The article's title promised breastfeeding coverage and already carried a LactMed reference for it, but a citation-integrity pass found that reference was never actually cited anywhere in the body — the breastfeeding half of the title had no matching content. Added the missing section and glance row rather than just wiring up the existing reference to a throwaway line.
Rewritten for length. The article repeated the same points across eight separate claim sections, and it's now four. Every citation, the funding disclosure, and all the caveats (the 2%-vs-4% hydroquinone comparison, the Cureus peer-review note, the concentration/formulation point, the null anti-ageing finding) are still here, just said once each instead of several times.
Corrected the niacinamide vs. hydroquinone melasma comparison. Earlier text implied a clearer niacinamide advantage, but the trial itself found no significant difference on colorimetry, with hydroquinone rated better on visual assessment by a slim margin (55% vs 44% good-to-excellent) and niacinamide causing fewer side effects (18% vs 29%). The article and glance table were rewritten to say what the trial actually measured, not what a summary of it implied.
Corrected the ceramide-ratio explanation. The piece previously described applying only one or two of the three lipid classes as merely failing to help, but the source trial actually found incomplete mixtures slow barrier repair below the rate of doing nothing at all. Rewrote the relevant section and the figure caption to say so plainly.
Downgraded collagen peptides from Grade B to Grade C after a 2025 meta-analysis sorted the existing trials by funding source: pooled together, the benefit looked real, but split apart, independently funded and higher-quality trials showed no effect on hydration, elasticity or wrinkles. The glance table, body text and grade were all updated to reflect this.
Added a disclosure that the 2023 systematic review underpinning several of this article's claims is authored entirely by staff of the Dermatica Institute of Clinical Excellence, which sells azelaic acid products. The findings themselves are unchanged, but the funding context is now attached throughout rather than mentioned once in passing.
No corrections logged yet. That's either a very good sign or an early one — check back as the archive grows.
Ask Stratum
Send us a claim, a question, or an ingredient
If you've seen a claim you want graded, or you're stuck between two ingredients and can't tell which one the evidence actually supports, this is the queue. Reader questions are where most of "Claims on trial" and a good few full articles come from.
Questions you've sent from this browser
Products
Whole formulas, checked against the formula's own claims
The Ingredient Index grades single actives. This does the same job on finished products — reading the full INCI ingredient list a brand actually publishes, checking whether the ingredient behind the marketing claim is really there and roughly where the label's own framing implies, and saying plainly when we can't verify the formula at all.
How this first batch checked out
14 products
Matches2
Partial12
Overstated0
Unverified0
Not an evidence grade — a check of whether each product's own marketing matches what it actually lists as ingredients. None of this batch had its headline ingredient missing or faked; the differences came down to secondary claims, unverifiable technology language, or an ingredient-safety nuance worth flagging.
How to read this section
We buy nothing on anyone's behalf and take nothing from any brand named here — this is the same non-negotiable as everything else on the site. INCI position is a real clue, not proof: cosmetic labelling rules only require descending order for ingredients above roughly 1% concentration; below that, order is often alphabetical. We say so per product rather than treating position as a verdict on its own. Every ingredient list below is sourced from the brand's own site and cross-checked against at least one independent source, and we tell you when sources disagreed instead of picking one silently. We link to each product's official page rather than reproducing the brand's own photography — the packaging icon here is ours, not theirs, and the link takes you to the real thing.
Nothing matches that combination. Try widening one of the dropdowns.
About
We publish the evidence, including when it's weak
Skincare has an incentive problem. The people with the most reach usually have something to sell, and a claim propped up by one small company-funded study reads exactly like one backed by a decade of proper trials.
Stratum exists to keep those two apart. Every claim is graded, sourced and dated, and we rewrite pieces when the research moves. We also try to write like humans, because an explanation nobody finishes reading isn't much use to anyone.
Who writes this
The Stratum Editors. We are not doctors, dermatologists or cosmetic chemists. We are researchers who got tired of skincare claims that nobody could trace back to anything, and started reading the papers instead.
That limitation is the reason this site is built the way it is. We can’t ask you to trust our judgement, so we don’t: every claim carries its study, its grade, and a link straight to PubMed or the DOI so you can check our work without taking our word for any of it. Where we have got something wrong, we say so in the corrections log rather than quietly editing it.
Stratum runs a two-tier trust system, not one blanket claim of authority. Every published piece is evidence-graded — sourced, checked against the literature, and rated using the same methodology every time. A smaller, visibly rarer set of pieces will additionally be clinician-reviewed, meaning a named, qualified reviewer has checked it before publication. No article here has reached that second tier yet. Every article says so plainly at the top. When one does, the byline will name who reviewed it and what they are qualified in — and it will look different from the rest, on purpose.
How a claim gets graded
We grade the claim, not the ingredient. The same molecule can hold a Grade A for one job and a Grade D for another, and we publish both rather than averaging them into something friendlier.
Where our sources come from
Peer-reviewed human studies, read in full rather than from the abstract. Where only the abstract was available to us, the reference says so.
Who paid for the research
If a study was funded by a company that sells the ingredient, that appears in the citation. It doesn't make the study wrong. It does tell you how surprised to be if the result shrinks later.
Money
Right now there is none. No product recommendations, no affiliate links, no sponsorship, nothing earned from anything we name. When that changes it will be for products you can actually buy in India, the disclosure will sit at the top of the article rather than at the bottom of the page, and we will flag it plainly when something we like sits outside what the research supports. That includes when saying so costs us the sale.
Why the author is not a doctor
Because he is not, and pretending otherwise would be the exact behaviour we exist to push against. The answer is not to claim authority but to remove the need for it: every claim is graded, sourced, and linked to the original paper so you can check it without trusting anyone. Articles reviewed by a clinician name the reviewer. Articles that have not been reviewed say so at the top.
How claims are worded
We describe what a study found, not what a product will do to you. 'A trial found X' rather than 'this cures X'. It is a duller way to write and the only accurate one.
Corrections
Mistakes get fixed in place, and we say what changed rather than quietly editing the sentence. If a correction changes what an article concludes, it goes at the top where you cannot miss it, and it is logged permanently on the corrections page. We would rather be publicly wrong once than quietly wrong forever.
What this isn't
General education, not medical care. Nothing here is a diagnosis or a treatment plan, and no article can account for your history, your medication or your skin.
The Sunday study
One paper a week, explained properly
We pick a single new study, tell you what it measured, how many people it measured it in, and whether it should change anything you're doing — plus the two articles we published that week. No panic, and no hype.
We don't recommend products yet. When we do, they'll be things you can actually buy in India, any affiliate link will be labelled as one, and a commission will never buy a recommendation.