StratumSkin science, cited
Ingredient Index

Keloid & scar-prone skin

Onion extract

Allium cepa extract gel, e.g. Mederma-type products

Overall grade DTypical strength Gel, applied several times daily3 sources

One of the most heavily marketed scar treatments, and one of the more disappointing ones once you look past the marketing. The cleanest trial we found (small, well-designed, split-scar, so each person acts as their own control) found no difference from plain petrolatum, which costs a fraction of the price and won't make your bathroom smell like a kitchen. A larger positive trial exists, but it was funded by the company selling the product and compared each scar against its own untreated half rather than a separate control gel. A meta-analysis on this exact question is, by its own title, unconvinced.

Claim by claim

DScar appearance vs. no active treatmentA well-designed split-scar RCT (n=24) found no statistically significant difference from plain petrolatum on any measure.
CScar appearance, industry-funded trialA trial funded by the product's manufacturer (n=44) reported a significant improvement, but each scar was compared against its own untreated half rather than a separate control gel. Treat it with more caution than the topline result suggests.
DVs. other topical scar treatmentsA meta-analysis of randomised trials on this exact question is titled, plainly, 'Onion extract gel is not better than other topical treatments in scar management.'

References

  1. Chung VQ, Kelley L, Marra D, Jiang SB. Onion extract gel versus petrolatum emollient on new surgical scars: prospective double-blinded study. Dermatologic Surgery, 2006.DProspective, randomised, double-blind, split-scar trial, n=24·A clean negative result: 'no statistically significant difference... in any of the outcome variables studied.' Split-scar design controls well for individual variation despite the small sample.PubMed 16442038
  2. Draelos ZD, Baumann L, Fleischer AB Jr, Plaum S, Avakian EV, Hardas B. A new proprietary onion extract gel improves the appearance of new scars: a randomized, controlled, blinded-investigator study. Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, 2012.CRandomised, controlled, single-blind-investigator study, n=44·Funded by the manufacturer (disclosed in the paper). The comparator was intra-patient: each scar's treated half was compared against its own untreated half, not a separate vehicle or placebo gel. Worth knowing before weighing 'significant improvement' too heavily.PubMed 22768353
  3. Yuan Y, et al. Onion extract gel is not better than other topical treatments in scar management: a meta-analysis from randomised controlled trials. International Wound Journal, 2021.DMeta-analysis of randomised controlled trials·The title states the finding plainly: onion extract gel did not outperform other topical scar treatments in the pooled trials.PubMed 33372412DOI 10.1111/iwj.13542

Related condition hub

Keloid & scar-prone skin

Your turn

Did this hold up? Tell us honestly — especially if it didn’t.

Anonymous. Stored in your browser.

The Sunday study

One paper a week, explained properly

We pick a single new study, tell you what it measured, how many people it measured it in, and whether it should change anything you're doing — plus the two articles we published that week. No panic, and no hype.

We don't recommend products yet. When we do, they'll be things you can actually buy in India, any affiliate link will be labelled as one, and a commission will never buy a recommendation.

One email each Sunday. Unsubscribe in one click.